Cook Out Desserts Menu 2026
Every Sweet Treat, What It Costs, and What to Actually Order
Cook Out is not just a fast-food stop; it also has one of the most underrated dessert menus in the USA. From thick hand-spun milkshakes with 40+ flavors to creamy cheesecakes, classic sundaes, and refreshing floats, every item is made fresh to order and served in generous portions starting from just 2$ to 4$.
What makes Cook Out desserts special is the combination of variety, freshness, and value. Whether you prefer rich chocolate shakes, fruity blends, or Southern-style desserts like banana pudding and peach cobbler, there is always something worth trying.
In this guide, you will get a complete breakdown of the Cook Out desserts menu, including milkshakes, cheesecakes, floats, seasonal favorites, and top recommendations, so you can easily decide what to order before visiting.
Prices at a Glance
Dessert
Price Range
Best Pick
|
Milkshakes |
$3.99 |
Peanut Butter Fudge |
|
Cheesecakes |
$2.49 – $2.69 |
Strawberry Cheesecake |
|
Floats |
$2.49 |
Cheerwine Float |
|
Soft-Serve Cone/Cup |
$1.99 – $2.09 |
Vanilla Cone |
|
Ice Cream Sundae |
$3.49 |
Fudge Sundae |
|
Banana Split |
$3.49 |
Classic Banana Split |
Prices can vary slightly by location. Cook Out runs across the Southeast and Mid-Atlantic, and while the menu stays mostly the same everywhere, small differences happen.
40+ Flavors · $3.99 Each
Milkshakes
Every shake is hand-spun with real ice cream and poured into a 30 to 35 oz cup. The thing most people don’t know: you can blend any two flavors for free. No upcharge, no questions. That’s the whole game. Regulars never order the same shake twice because of this.
Vanilla $3.99
Clean and smooth. Best mixer on the menu if you’re blending.
Chocolate $3.99
Dense, deep cocoa. More dessert than drink.
Strawberry $3.99
It is light and fruity. Real strawberry sweetness, not candy-fake.
Cherry $3.99
Maraschino-style sweetness blended into vanilla ice cream.
Fresh Banana $3.99
Tastes like real bananas. Not the artificial extract stuff.
Caramel $3.99
Buttery and rich. Like liquid caramel candy.
Cappuccino $3.99
Bold coffee flavor with a light sweetness underneath.
Mocha $3.99
Chocolate meets coffee, neither one overpowering the other.
Lemon $3.99
Tart citrus cut with cream. Surprisingly excellent in summer.
Blackberry $3.99
Bold and tangy. Fuller than the lighter fruit options.
Fruit Flavors
These are lighter and more refreshing than the candy shakes. Good when you want something sweet without the weight of mix-ins.
Banana Berry $3.99
Banana and mixed berry with a creamy finish.
Banana Pineapple $3.99
Tropical and naturally sweet. Summer in a cup.
Banana Pudding $3.99
Custardy, warm, and very Southern.
Banana Nut $3.99
Fresh banana with a subtle nut richness.
Banana Fudge $3.99
Banana and chocolate fudge together.
Blueberry $3.99
Gentle tartness rounds off into a smooth finish.
Peach $3.99
Sweet Georgia peach flavor, exactly what it should be.
Peach Cobbler $3.99
A 34.5 oz pour with warm, spiced peach. One of the best shakes on the menu, period.
Orange Push-Up $3.99
That orange-cream popsicle from childhood in shake form.
Pineapple $3.99
Tangy, tropical, light. Works alone or blended with banana.
The peach cobbler shake is worth calling out. It tastes like a warm homemade peach cobbler made into a milkshake cup. And the 34.5 oz size makes it the best volume deal in the fruit category.
Chocolate & Candy Flavors
Cook Out blends actual candy pieces into these, not syrup or flavoring, real candy. The texture gets thick and chunky. Some people skip dinner entirely after one of these.
$3.99
Oreo
Real crushed Oreo pieces through every sip.
$3.99
Oreo Mint Peppermint
Freshness meets Oreo crunch.
$3.99
Reese’s Cup
Real Reese’s pieces with peanut butter and chocolate.
$3.99
Snickers
Chocolate, caramel, and peanuts. Tastes like a melted Snickers bar.
$3.99
M&M
M&M pieces mixed into thick ice cream for extra crunch.
$3.99
Heath Toffee
Buttery toffee with a warm caramel edge.
$3.99
Butterfinger
Crunchy butterscotch-peanut pieces in every sip.
$3.99
Double Chocolate
Twice the depth. This variety is for serious chocolate fans only.
$3.99
Mint Chocolate Chip
Classic cool mint with real chocolate chips.
$3.99
Chocolate Malt
Old-school malt flavor adds depth beyond regular chocolate.
$3.99
Chocolate Cherry
Dark cherry and rich chocolate. More elegant than most candy shakes.
$3.99
Caramel Fudge
Caramel and chocolate fudge layered together.
The Oreo shake is the most popular in this category. Rightfully so. But the Snickers shake is what keeps people coming back; it genuinely tastes like a melted candy bar.
Peanut Butter & Nut Flavors
The heaviest shakes on the menu. The peanut butter lineup has a serious following.
$3.99
Peanut Butter Fudge
This is the most ordered shake on the entire menu. Peanut butter and chocolate fudge.
$3.99
Peanut Butter Banana
Banana’s natural sweetness balances the richness of peanut butter well.
$3.99
Fresh Peanut Butter
Pure peanut butter flavor. Thick, rich, no distractions.
$3.99
Walnut
Smooth roasted walnut with a more complex edge than the candy shakes.
Limited Time
Seasonal Shakes
These rotate throughout the year. If one is on the board when you pull up, just order it. They don’t stay long.
Fresh Watermelon
Summer (June – August)
Peach Cobbler
Late Summer / Early Fall
Pumpkin Pie
Fall (September – November)
Eggnog
Winter (November – January)
Peppermint
Winter (December – January)
The fresh watermelon shake gets people excited every June when it comes back. It tastes like cold, fresh-cut watermelon blended with cream, somehow light and indulgent at the same time. The peppermint and eggnog shakes in winter are just as worth getting.
$2.49 – $2.69
Cheesecake
Real cheesecake. Not a bite-sized piece, not cheesecake flavoring, but actual cold, creamy slices with toppings. At under $2.70, it is the most underrated item on the whole menu. Most people walk past it without knowing it exists.
$2.49
Classic Cheesecake
Smooth and tangy on a buttery crust made from graham crackers.
$2.69
Strawberry Cheesecake
Sweet strawberry sauce over the classic base. The most popular of the four.
$2.69
Chocolate Cheesecake
Cocoa-infused base with chocolate drizzle. Denser and richer.
$2.69
Caramel Cheesecake
Silky caramel sauce over the creamy base. Underrated.
$2.49 Each
Floats
Vanilla soft-serve with ice-cold soda poured over it. The ice cream slowly melts into the soda, the soda gets cold and slightly creamy, and somewhere between those two things, you have one of the best $2.49 desserts in fast food. Lighter than a milkshake, cheaper than a sundae.
$2.49
Cheerwine Float
Cheerwine is a cherry soda from North Carolina, made since 1917. Sweet, slightly tart, unlike any cola. Poured over soft serve, it is one of the most distinctly Southern things you can get through a drive-thru window.
$2.69
Root Beer Float
The timeless one. Works every single time.
$2.69
Coke Float
Coca-Cola’s sharpness cuts through the creaminess well.
$2.69
Fanta Orange Float
Citrusy and bright. It tastes like a creamsicle.
Ice Cream
$1.99
Soft-Serve Cone
Vanilla soft-serve in a classic cone. Cheapest dessert on the menu.
$2.09
Soft-Serve Cup
Same thing, easier to eat in the car without it melting on you.
3.49
Fudge Sundae
Soft-serve with hot fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry. A full sundae for a fast-food price.
$3.49
Strawberry Sundae
Vanilla soft-serve with strawberry sauce. Lighter than the fudge version.
$3.49
Banana Split
Fresh banana, soft-serve, and three toppings: fudge, strawberry, and caramel. The most complete dessert on the menu.
Nutrition
Calorie Reference
Item
Price
Est. Calories
|
Peanut Butter Fudge Shake |
$3.99 |
~950 |
|
Reese’s Cup Shake |
$3.99 |
~910 |
|
Snickers Shake |
$3.99 |
~900 |
|
Oreo Shake |
$3.99 |
~880 |
|
Peach Cobbler Shake |
$3.99 |
~800 |
|
Banana Pudding Shake |
$3.99 |
~760 |
|
Fresh Watermelon Shake |
$3.99 |
~680 |
|
Classic Cheesecake |
$2.49 |
~470 |
|
Strawberry Cheesecake |
$2.69 |
~520 |
|
Cheerwine Float |
$2.49 |
~380 |
|
Root Beer Float |
$2.49 |
~370 |
|
Banana Split |
$3.49 |
~580 |
|
Fudge Sundae |
$3.49 |
~540 |
|
Soft-Serve Cone |
$1.99 |
~250 |
The lightest option is the soft-serve cone at around 250 calories. The heaviest is Peanut Butter Fudge at around 950. Floats and cheesecakes are your best options if you want something satisfying without going all the way.
Insider Tip
Blends Worth Trying (All Free)
Blending two flavors costs nothing. Regulars have been doing these blends for years, and most of these combinations are better than any single flavor on the menu.
The Banana Split Shake
How to order: Strawberry + Banana + Chocolate Chip
The Elvis
How to order: Fresh Banana + Peanut Butter
Strawberry Cheesecake Shake
How to order: Strawberry + Cheesecake
Oreo Cheesecake
How to order: Oreo + Cheesecake
Southern Gold
How to order: Banana Pudding + Caramel + Walnut
Tropical Bliss
How to order: Pineapple + Watermelon + Strawberry (summer only)
Peppermint Bark
How to order: Peppermint + Double Chocolate (winter only)
The Monster
How to order: Peanut Butter Fudge + Snickers
Comparison
Cook Out vs. Other Chains
Item
Price
Est. Calories
Est. Calories
|
Cook Out |
30–35 oz |
$3.99 |
40+ |
|
McDonald’s |
~22 oz |
$4.29 |
4–5 |
|
Chick-fil-A |
~20 oz |
$4.75 |
6–8 |
|
Sonic |
~20 oz |
$4.99 |
10–12 |
|
Shake Shack |
~16 oz |
$7.49 |
6–10 |
|
Five Guys |
~24 oz |
$7.99 |
10+ |
You get a bigger size, more flavors, a lower price, and you can blend in a second flavor for free. That is hard to beat anywhere.
Frequently Asked Questions
Final Verdict: Cook Out Desserts You Should Not Miss
Cook Out desserts are popular because they offer more than just taste; they deliver variety, freshness, and unbeatable value. From thick milkshakes and classic sundaes to real cheesecake slices and seasonal limited-time flavors, every dessert feels freshly made and satisfying.
With so many options available at budget-friendly prices starting from just $2 to $4, it is easy to understand why customers keep coming back. If you are visiting Cook Out, skipping the dessert menu would be a mistake because it often becomes the most memorable part of the meal.
Once you try it, you will likely find yourself coming back just for the desserts alone.